In their zeal to achieve a reduced carbon environment, Democrats have been promoting nuclear energy as a safe, clean energy source. Some states are moving as quickly as they can to reactivate idle reactors. In 2022, Congress passed the Inflation Relief Act (IRA) which contained a provision to provide thirty billion dollars for nuclear subsidies.
Scandals involving bribery over nuclear energy have brought down high-level state officials and corporate executives in Ohio, Illinois and other places.
In 2020, federal prosecutors presented charges against officials of Commonwealth Edison (ComEd), an Illinois company. They were charged with offering jobs and favors to friends of the Speaker of the Illinois House of Representatives in exchange for a bill to bailout the company’s nuclear division.
At about the same time, Ohio-based FirstEnergy executives were charged with paying sixty million dollars in bribes to state legislators. Former Ohio Speaker of the House Larry Householder is currently serving a forty-seven-year prison sentence.
Floodlight is a non-profit environmental news service. They published a piece in the liberal magazine Mother Jones that perfectly showcases the corruption in the nuclear industry. The article said, “Utility fraud and corruption—in Florida, Illinois, Mississippi, Ohio, and South Carolina—have cost electricity customers at least $6.6 billion, according to Floodlight’s analysis. Ratepayers have bankrolled nuclear plants that never got built, transmission systems that were over-engineered to beef up profits, and aging coal facilities that couldn’t compete with cheaper plants powered by methane, which the industry calls natural gas.”
Before these scandals developed, and before Congress passed the Inflation Recovery Act, the nuclear industry had become so unpopular that it was a tempting target for political corruption.
The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists said, “Changes in the economics of electricity markets are threatening the profitability of nuclear power plants, a shifting reality driving a demand for these financial bailouts. As the New Jersey-based energy company Public Service Enterprise Group (PSEG) explained in October 2020, across the nation “nuclear plants continue to struggle economically to survive. Since 2018, three nuclear plants have closed in the eastern US, all for economic reasons, and the impact has had a ripple effect.”
Over the past few years, the U.S. Justice Department and the courts have carried out their jobs in prosecuting and sentencing bad actors in the nuclear industry. Now, it is time for Congress to investigate the root causes of the corruption. Executives and experts from the nuclear industry must be brought before congressional committees to explain why their industry has been allowed to fall into corruption at the expense of the taxpayer and the consumer.
Congress must fulfill its investigative role and discover why this corruption keeps happening. The first witness called to testify should be the Secretary of Energy, Jennifer Granholm. She should inform members of the House and Senate why uncompetitive nuclear plants are being propped up. If they cannot compete, they should be shuttered.
The head of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) should be pressed to give a full accounting of all nuclear reactors in the U.S. This account should include how many are in working order.
Former Ohio Speaker Larry Householder should be brought before the committee in his prison jumpsuit to explain why bribery was thought to be a solution to inefficient energy.
State governors should be asked to explain their plans for providing energy to their states if a particular source is no longer viable.
The list of those responsible for the growth of corruption in the nuclear industry is long. However, more needs to be done than simply punishing the criminals. Congress must take the lead in finding out why an unreliable and dangerous energy source is ripe for corruption.